ATMs in Phoenicia, New York, the US. ATMs locations in Phoenicia, New York. Find the nearest atms locations, near you. All types of business services ATM Bank Finance Real estate School All atms in Phoenicia ATM ATM Finance 57 Main Street, Phoenicia, New York 12464 Write a review Phone Directions Closed now Until 08:30 am KeyBank ATM Finance Bank +1 845-688-7000 53 Main Street, Phoenicia, New York 12464 Write a review Phone Hours Website Directions Open now Open 24 Hours KeyBank ATM ATM Finance +1 800-539-2968 53 Main Street, Phoenicia, New York 12464 Write a review Phone Hours Website Directions